New York: Broadway Comedy Club All Star Stand-Up Comedy Live

If you’re headed to New York City and want a night filled with genuine laughs, the Broadway Comedy Club offers a solid option. This venue hosts some of the best stand-up comedians from NYC and beyond, many of whom have appeared on Comedy Central, HBO, and Saturday Night Live. Our review isn’t based on personal attendance, but on traveler feedback and the overall vibe of this comedy night.

What makes this experience stand out? First, the intimate setting ensures all seats are close to the stage, creating a warm, engaging atmosphere. Second, the chance to see TV comedians live — plus the opportunity to grab a drink and chat with fellow comedy lovers. Third, it offers exceptional value at just $19, especially considering the caliber of comedy on display.

However, a potential consideration is the two-drink minimum policy, which can add to the cost if you’re not careful — but hey, it’s part of the comedy club experience. This experience is perfect for those looking for a lively night out with authentic humor, whether you’re visiting NYC for the first time or a local wanting a reliable comedy fix.

Key Points

• Intimate Venue: All seats are close to the stage, making for a personal comedy experience.
• TV-Comedians: The lineup features well-known comedians who have appeared on popular shows and networks.
• Affordable Price: Tickets are roughly $19, offering good value for top-tier comedy.
• Two-Drink Minimum: Expect to purchase at least 2 drinks, which can increase the bill.
• Flexible Cancellation: Free cancellation available 24 hours in advance.
• Accessibility: The venue is wheelchair accessible, catering to all guests.

You can check availability for your dates here:

The Venue and Atmosphere

The Broadway Comedy Club is located in the heart of Times Square, making it a convenient stop after sightseeing or other city adventures. The club’s layout is designed to foster an engaging environment—no one wants to be stuck at the back, and with all seats close to the stage, you’ll feel like part of the action. Guests often comment on the friendly vibe and the professional setup, which balances a lively night with a cozy, less intimidating feel than larger comedy halls.

Many reviews mention how the comedians are both talented and approachable, often interacting with the crowd. One reviewer noted, “the comedians were great, and the venue had a very good set of guests.” The intimate nature of the venue is frequently praised, with one guest saying, “you could talk to other people because the tables are close, which is a nice change from typical chairs in other countries.”

The Lineup and Comedy Quality

Expect a rotating cast of top headliners, many of whom have appeared on MTV, HBO, The Tonight Show, Comedy Central, and other major platforms. The lineup changes regularly, but you can generally count on a mix of newcomers learning their craft and seasoned comedians with years of experience. Several reviewers highlight the quality and humor of the acts, with comments like “cracking set, brilliant comedians, some new and some very experienced.”

One reviewer appreciated the diversity, noting, “eight comedians ranging in ability, but most were very good,” and even pointing out that some acts are still perfecting their trade. The fact that comedians sometimes drop in spontaneously or ask for stage time keeps each show feeling fresh and unpredictable.

What to Expect During the Show

The show typically runs for about 1.5 hours, although it can run slightly longer. You’ll see a lineup of several comedians, each delivering their unique style—some quick-witted, some more observational, others leaning into satire. It’s common to experience a variety of humor, which keeps the audience engaged and laughing throughout.

A recurring theme among reviewers was the quality of the acts—many found the comedians hilarious, with some even surprised at the professional level of humor. One guest mentioned, “acts were great but over very quickly,” which is understandable given the brief but punchy format.

The two-drink minimum is enforced, with options including both alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages. Many reviews mention that drinks can be pricey—Sprite at $9 or a mojito at $16—but that’s typical for NYC. Some guests tip extra, adding to the overall expense, so budgeting for drinks is wise.

Food and Drinks

While the focus is on comedy, the venue offers inexpensive drinks during the show, making it easy to sip and relax. The reviews vary on drink quality; some say the drinks are a bit overpriced but acceptable, with one noting, “the cost and quality of the drinks could be better.” Snacks or food options are limited, so don’t expect a full meal.

However, many reviewers have found the combination of comedy and drinks to be a good value overall. One guest who left a tip appreciated the friendly service, and another pointed out that the drinks are a good way to loosen up for the comedy.

More Great Tours Nearby

Accessibility and Convenience

The venue is wheelchair accessible, making it a welcoming space for all guests. Entry is straightforward—just present your confirmation at the box office, and you can arrive up to 30 minutes before the show begins. The show is held primarily in the evening, and the flexible cancellation policy (cancel up to 24 hours in advance) gives travelers peace of mind.

People also appreciate the ease of booking via platforms like GetYourGuide, which allows for reserve-now, pay-later options, providing flexibility in planning your night out.

Authentic Insights from Reviewers

Many guests have shared their experiences, and they paint a realistic picture. One wrote that the comedians are locals, with some of the acts being “learning their trade,” which makes the show feel genuine and unpretentious. Another mentioned that the show can be short but sweet, with some acts being more memorable than others, but overall a worthwhile night.

Some reviewers warn about the cost of drinks—Sprite at $9 and cocktails at $16—so come prepared to budget accordingly if drinks are your thing. One guest pointed out that an 18% automatic gratuity is added to the bill, with an extra tip expected, so be aware of the total bill before ordering.

Who Is This Experience Perfect For?

This comedy night is ideal for solo travelers, couples, or small groups seeking a fun, authentic NYC experience. If you enjoy live comedy and want to see comedians who have performed on prestigious stages, you’ll find this show satisfying. It’s also a good choice if you’re looking for a budget-friendly night out with laughs included.

The venue’s intimate setting makes it especially appealing for those who prefer a more personal vibe over larger, impersonal comedy halls. Keep in mind, if you’re sensitive to language or adult humor, check the comedian lineup, as some material can be risqué.

Final Thoughts

The Broadway Comedy Club delivers a solid comedy experience with top-tier performers in a cozy, intimate setting. The tickets are affordable, especially considering the quality of comedians, and the informal vibe creates a relaxed, enjoyable atmosphere.

While drinks can add to the overall expense, the overall value for a night of authentic NYC comedy remains high. If you’re craving a lively, laughter-filled evening that’s easy to access and reliable, this venue is a dependable choice.

For travelers who love comedy, casual venues, and the chance to see TV comedians live, the Broadway Comedy Club offers a night worth remembering—just come with a sense of humor and a little extra for drinks!

FAQ

Is there a dress code for the comedy club?
No formal dress code is specified, but casual, neat attire is appropriate for a relaxed NYC night out.

Can I book tickets in advance?
Yes, tickets are available online, with options to reserve now and pay later. This helps secure your spot and plan ahead.

What is the typical duration of the show?
The show lasts about 1.5 hours, although it might run slightly longer depending on the lineup and any spontaneous stage requests from comedians.

Are drinks included in the ticket price?
No, drinks are not included; there’s a two-drink minimum policy, and drinks must be purchased during the show.

Is the venue wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the Broadway Comedy Club is wheelchair accessible, accommodating all guests comfortably.

Can I bring children?
The show isn’t suitable for children under 12 due to adult humor and language.

What if I need to cancel my reservation?
You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, providing flexibility in case your plans change.

You can check availability for your dates here: