Explore the captivating world of New York City’s organized crime history and savor the flavors of authentic Italian cuisine on this unique tour. Led by retired NYPD detectives, participants uncover the criminal and culinary legacies of Little Italy and the East Village, exploring notorious Mafia strongholds and indulging in classic dishes like spaghetti and meatballs. With insights that only former law enforcement can provide, this 3.5-hour adventure promises an unforgettable experience for anyone fascinated by the intersection of crime and cuisine.

Contents show

Key Points

This 3.5-hour tour offers an immersive experience exploring Mafia strongholds in East Village and Little Italy, led by retired NYPD detectives.
Guests can savor classic Italian dishes while learning about notorious Mafia bosses and their illicit operations in the neighborhoods.
The tour includes a visit to Johns of 12th Street, a renowned "Mafia red sauce joint" that was a gathering place for the criminal underworld.
Participants can indulge in authentic Sicilian cannoli and explore the cultural roots and architectural beauty of Little Italy.
The former NYPD detectives provide first-hand insights into the Mafia’s history, structure, and influence in New York City.

You can check availability for your dates here:

Tour Overview

This NYC: Mafia Experience and Local Food with NYPD Guide tour offers a unique opportunity to explore the East Village and Little Italy neighborhoods, which were key areas of Mafia activity in New York City.

The tour is led by retired NYPD detectives with firsthand experience in organized crime, providing guests with exclusive insights into the history and crime stories of the Mafia.

Priced at $149 per person, the 3.5-hour tour includes food tastings, such as spaghetti and meatballs, eggplant parmigiana, and Sicilian cannoli.

The 3.5-hour tour offers a taste of classic Italian dishes, including spaghetti and meatballs, eggplant parmigiana, and Sicilian cannoli, at $149 per person.

The tour is wheelchair-accessible and has a 4.8/5 overall rating based on 100 reviews.

Here are more experiences we've reviewed in New York City

Exploring the East Village and Little Italy

As the tour ventures into the East Village and Little Italy, guests are immersed in the heart of New York City’s historic Mafia strongholds.

Led by retired NYPD detectives, the group explores the neighborhoods that once teemed with notorious criminal activity. Guests witness firsthand the sites where Mafia bosses and their crews operated, learning about the infamous families and their illicit dealings.

Food stops at local restaurants provide a taste of classic Italian-American cuisine, from spaghetti and meatballs to Sicilian cannoli, complementing the insights into the Mafia’s culinary traditions and influences.

Mafia Red Sauce Joint: Johns of 12th Street

The tour begins at Johns of 12th Street, a longtime mainstay in the East Village and a renowned "Mafia red sauce joint." This Italian-American restaurant has been a gathering place for New York’s criminal underworld for decades, making it the perfect starting point to explore the city’s organized crime history. The guides share captivating stories of Mafia bosses and their connections to this hotel, revealing the intertwined relationship between the mob and the local community. The group settles in for a delicious meal, savoring the robust flavors that have sustained generations of mobsters and their families.

| Criminal Connections | Establishment Details | Significance |

| — | — | — |

| Mafia bosses frequent Johns of 12th Street | Longtime East Village institution | Perfect starting point for Mafia tour |

| Criminal underworld gathers at the restaurant | Renowned "Mafia red sauce joint" | Illustrates intertwined relationship between mob and community |

| Guides share stories of mob ties to the hotel | Italian-American cuisine served for decades | Sustains generations of mobsters and families |

| Captivating insights into organized crime history | Gathering place for New York’s criminal element | Provides context for understanding the Mafia’s influence |

| Delicious meal at the iconic restaurant | Authentic Italian-American dining experience | Connects the culinary and criminal aspects of the tour |

Culinary Delights of Little Italy

After savoring the robust flavors at the Mafia red sauce joint, the tour proceeds to the vibrant neighborhood of Little Italy.

The group explores the historic streets and learns about the area’s deep cultural roots.

Highlights include:

Tasting authentic Sicilian cannoli from a renowned local bakery
Browsing the artisanal shops and markets that line the bustling sidewalks
Admiring the ornate architecture and lively atmosphere that define this iconic NYC enclave
Hearing captivating stories about the Mafia’s influence and criminal activities in the neighborhood

The culinary delights and immersive cultural experience make this stop a memorable part of the overall tour.

More Great Tours Nearby

Dessert Stop

Following the satiating meal of Italian favorites, the tour makes a final stop to indulge in a delectable Sicilian dessert. The group is treated to a traditional Sicilian cannoli, a flaky pastry shell filled with a rich, creamy ricotta-based filling. This sweet ending to the culinary journey provides a delightful contrast to the savory dishes sampled earlier. As the group savors the cannoli, the guide shares insights into the Sicilian roots of this beloved dessert and its connection to the Mafia’s influence in the neighborhood.

| Dessert Stop | Description | Significance |

| — | — | — |

| Sicilian Cannoli | Flaky pastry shell filled with creamy ricotta-based filling | Traditional Sicilian dessert with ties to Mafia history in the area |

| Flavor Profile | Sweet, decadent | Provides a satisfying conclusion to the Italian meal |

| Tasting Experience | Savored by the group | Offers a final taste of local cuisine and culture |

| Guide Commentary | Insights into Sicilian origins and Mafia connections | Enhances the educational and immersive nature of the tour |

Hungry for more New York City flavors? We've covered these other food and drink spots

Sightseeing and Walking

As the group bids farewell to the indulgent cannoli, the tour continues with additional sightseeing and walking through the neighborhood.

The retired NYPD detectives guide the participants on an engaging exploration of the area, providing unique insights into the Mafia’s historical presence.

Key highlights include:

Identifying former Mafia hangouts and safe houses
Discussing infamous mob-related incidents and crimes
Pointing out architectural elements that held significance during the Prohibition era
Sharing first-hand anecdotes from their law enforcement careers

The walking portion allows for a deeper appreciation of the neighborhood’s rich history and the Mafia’s lasting influence on the fabric of New York City.

Insights From Former NYPD Detectives

The retired NYPD detectives leading the tour utilize their firsthand experience to provide unparalleled insights into the inner workings of the Mafia.

With intimate knowledge of organized crime investigations, they offer unique perspectives on the Mafia’s history, structure, and notorious figures.

Guests gain a deeper understanding of the Mafia’s code of silence, intricate power dynamics, and ruthless methods.

The guides’ gripping first-hand accounts and crime stories bring the Mafia’s influence on New York City to life, captivating participants and painting a vivid picture of this underworld.

Their expertise elevates the tour, delivering an immersive and educational experience.

Important Details and Recommendations

Though the tour is wheelchair accessible, it’s important for participants to wear comfortable shoes and dress appropriately for the weather.

The tour isn’t suitable for children under 8 years old. Guests should bring the following items:

Comfortable shoes
Weather-appropriate clothing
Optional drinks for purchase
Tips for the guide

The tour includes walking, food tastings, and insights from former NYPD detectives.

While the overall value and experience have received high ratings, it’s essential for visitors to be aware of the tour’s requirements and limitations to ensure an enjoyable and informative mafia-themed outing in New York City.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Tour Wheelchair Accessible Throughout the Entire Route?

The tour is wheelchair accessible throughout the entire route. The overview states that the tour is "Wheelchair accessible", indicating the walking tour and food stops can accommodate guests using wheelchairs.

Can I Take Photos During the Tour?

According to the tour overview, participants are allowed to take photos during the guided tour. The itinerary does not mention any restrictions on photography, so guests can capture the sights and experiences throughout the 3.5-hour experience.

Are There Any Vegetarian or Gluten-Free Food Options Available?

The tour accommodates vegetarian and gluten-free diets. Guests can request these special dietary options when booking, and the guide will ensure the food stops cater to their needs during the experience.

Can I Purchase Alcoholic Beverages During the Food Tastings?

The tour doesn’t explicitly mention alcoholic beverages being available during the food tastings. However, drinks can be purchased separately at the various food stops, so guests may be able to order alcoholic options if they choose.

Is There a Minimum Group Size Required to Book the Tour?

No, there’s no minimum group size required to book the tour. Individuals can sign up and join other solo travelers on the group experience.

The Sum Up

This NYC: Mafia Experience and Local Food tour offers a unique blend of organized crime history and authentic Italian cuisine. Led by retired NYPD detectives, the 3.5-hour adventure takes participants through the East Village and Little Italy, visiting Mafia hotspots and indulging in classic dishes like spaghetti and meatballs, and Sicilian cannoli. It’s an immersive experience that provides captivating insights into the culinary and criminal past of these vibrant neighborhoods.