10:30pm Shadows of the Supernatural Tour

When it comes to exploring haunted cities, St. Augustine is a top contender. Known for its centuries-old buildings and atmospheric streets, it’s a place where history and ghostly tales often go hand in hand. The 10:30 pm Shadows of the Supernatural Tour promises a deeper look into this city’s eerie side, emphasizing genuine research and true stories rather than urban legends. While we haven’t personally taken this tour, reviews suggest it’s a compelling experience that balances history with paranormal investigation.

What we love about this tour:

• It’s thoroughly researched — no silly urban legends here, just real stories and evidence
• The knowledgeable guides share fascinating insights, photos, and paranormal recordings
• The late-night atmosphere makes for an authentic spooky experience, adding to the thrill
• It covers less-visited sites most travelers wouldn’t explore alone, offering a unique perspective

One potential consideration is the group size—limited to 30 travelers—which helps maintain an intimate feeling but might mean booking well in advance, especially during peak seasons. This tour is ideal for history buffs, paranormal fans, or anyone wanting a different kind of night out in St. Augustine.

Key Points

• Authentic stories and research make this tour stand out
• The guides are praised for their knowledge and engaging storytelling
• The itinerary includes historic cemeteries, haunted buildings, and mysterious sites
• Paranormal evidence like photos and recordings are shared during the tour
• The tour operates at night, enhancing the spooky ambiance
• It offers great value at only $25 per person, considering the depth of stories and site visits

What to Expect from the Shadows of the Supernatural Tour

This 1.5-hour tour is designed to take you on a walk through some of St. Augustine’s most haunted sites, combining historical facts with ghostly investigations. Starting at the A1A Ale Works Restaurant, the tour winds through a series of significant locations, each with its own paranormal tales.

The First Stop: Tolomato Cemetery

Our journey begins at this historic cemetery, where the guide shares haunted history and presents paranormal evidence captured there. The cemetery’s long-standing history makes it a perfect first stop for setting a mysterious tone. Reviewers mention that the stories about haunted graves and paranormal recordings made here add a genuine spooky flavor. The guide’s thorough research helps dispel urban legend and focus on factual accounts, which many appreciate.

Potter’s Wax Museum

Next, you visit one of the city’s oldest buildings, now a wax museum, but with a haunted past. The guide discusses the building’s history and presents evidence collected during investigations—adding credibility to the ghost stories. The haunted reputation of this site is well-known locally, and sharing paranormal recordings gives a tangible feel, especially for those skeptical about supernatural tales.

38 Cordova Street

This stop brings us to the site of the haunted Memories Room, home to a little ghost girl. The stories of Faye Sheldon’s spirit and the paranormal evidence shared make this a memorable highlight. As one reviewer states, “Bill was an awesome guide,” emphasizing how engaging storytelling makes all the difference. Expect to see photos and hear recordings, making the experience more immersive.

Casablanca Inn on the Bay

During the walk past the Casablanca Inn, the story of architect Goold Butler’s ghost is told. Paranormal evidence from investigations here adds credibility, and the late-night setting amplifies the eerie atmosphere. Guests often comment on how the stories make the historic building come alive with ghostly presence.

Oldest Wooden School House

This stop combines a look at the school’s history with tales of ghost children haunting the premises. Paranormal evidence shared during the tour helps bring the stories into focus, offering a tangible connection to the spirits said to linger. Reviewers highlight that the mix of history and supernatural tales keeps the tour interesting and engaging.

Prince Murat House

The final stop features the well-known spirit of Faye Sheldon and stories of other hauntings. Paranormal evidence shared during the investigation here leaves a lasting impression. Many appreciate this as a fitting end to the tour, tying together the night’s haunted theme.

Why This Tour Works for Travelers

The tour’s appeal lies in its research-based approach. Unlike many ghost tours that rely solely on urban legends, this experience emphasizes factual stories, paranormal evidence, and documented investigations. This makes it particularly attractive to those who want a credible, story-driven experience.

The guides—notably Bill and Nicolas—are consistently praised for their knowledgeable, friendly, and engaging style. Their ability to share paranormal evidence, including photos and recordings, creates a more tangible connection to the ghost stories. Many reviews mention how these elements elevate the experience, making it more than just a walk and story session.

The timing at night adds ambiance, with the darkness and quiet streets heightening the sense of mystery. The group size (up to 30 people) means you’re not lost in a crowd, allowing for more interaction and a personal feel. Plus, the price of $25 per person is considered very reasonable given the depth of information, the investigation evidence, and the unique locations visited.

However, some reviews note that the tour can be affected by external distractions like noise or busy streets, making some moments less immersive. It’s worth being prepared for some ambient city sounds or interruptions, especially in a lively tourist spot like St. Augustine.

Deep Dive Into the Itinerary

Tolomato Cemetery is a great starting point because it offers a peaceful, historic setting with a haunted reputation. The stories of paranormal activity, supported by evidence, give an authentic feel. Expect a brief stop, but one packed with spooky tales and insights into the cemetery’s history, which many reviews highlight as a favorite.

Potter’s Wax Museum provides a different kind of haunted experience—an old building with a haunted history. The paranormal evidence shared from investigations here helps solidify its status as a site of paranormal activity. Visitors will learn about the ghostly legends linked to the building, and the evidence gives a real sense of the supernatural.

38 Cordova Street is especially memorable for the ghost girl haunting the Memories Room. The story of Faye Sheldon is a local legend, and sharing photographs and recordings during the tour makes the ghostly encounter more vivid. Reviewers often mention how the paranormal evidence shared helped them feel the stories were genuine.

Casablanca Inn on the Bay is another highlight, where stories of architect Goold Butler’s spirit are told. The paranormal evidence shared during investigations enhances the ghostly reputation of this historic inn, making it a favorite for those interested in haunted hospitality.

Oldest Wooden School House offers a combination of its educational past and ghost children stories, which many find both charming and spooky. The paranormal evidence shared here provides tangible proof that spirits may still linger in the old structure.

Finally, Prince Murat House is considered a key location, featuring Faye Sheldon’s ghost and other mysterious happenings. Many reviews praise the sharing of paranormal evidence—photos and recordings—that make the stories more believable.

What Travelers Say

Feedback from previous guests shows consistent praise for the knowledgeability of the guides—most notably Bill and Nicolas. One reviewer calls Nicolas “fun and interesting,” while another appreciates Bill for making the stories “exciting and well-researched.” Many mention the sharing of paranormal evidence—photos, recordings, and personal experiences—that bring the stories to life.

Some point out that the pacing is generally good, although a few mention external distractions like noise affecting the experience. Others highlight how the nighttime setting and visits to less-visited sites make for a memorable evening.

A few critics feel the tour might not meet expectations if you’re looking for a more dramatic or theatrical ghost experience. But for those who want credible stories, historical context, and real paranormal evidence, this tour hits the mark.

The Sum Up

The 10:30 pm Shadows of the Supernatural Tour offers a well-balanced, authentic look at St. Augustine’s haunted history. With thorough research, engaging storytelling, and genuine paranormal evidence, it’s perfect for travelers who crave a credible, atmospheric ghost walk. The combination of history, investigation results, and eerie locations makes it more than just a typical ghost tour—it’s an immersive, thought-provoking experience.

This tour is especially suited for those interested in historical accuracy alongside supernatural tales, or anyone who wants a late-night adventure that feels both fun and educational. The price point is reasonable considering the depth of stories and evidence shared, making it good value for money.

For anyone seeking a spooky evening that respects the city’s history while exploring its ghostly legends, this tour delivers. Just remember to wear comfortable shoes, bring a sense of curiosity, and prepare for an atmospheric walk through one of America’s most haunted towns.

FAQs

Is the tour suitable for children?
Most travelers can participate, but the late-hour and spooky themes might be better suited for teenagers and adults. Check with the provider if you have younger children.

How long is the tour?
It lasts approximately 1 hour and 30 minutes, covering about six different locations.

Do I need to book in advance?
Yes, this tour is often booked about 13 days in advance, and spots are limited to 30 travelers per session.

What is the meeting point?
It starts at A1A Ale Works Restaurant & Taproom, 1 King St, St. Augustine.

Is it easy to find parking nearby?
Yes, the meeting point is in a central area with nearby parking options. It is also near public transportation.

What is included in the ticket price?
The $25 fee covers the guided walk, paranormal stories, evidence sharing, and investigation insights. No additional tickets are needed for the stops.

Are service animals allowed?
Yes, service animals are permitted on the tour.

What should I bring?
Comfortable shoes are recommended for walking, and a flashlight might come in handy given the nighttime setting.

In summary, the Shadows of the Supernatural Tour is a captivating way to experience St. Augustine beyond the typical sightseeing. It combines authentic research, paranormal evidence, and engaging storytelling to give a truly memorable night exploring the haunted side of this historic city. Whether you’re a skeptic or a believer, you’re likely to come away with a new appreciation for the ghostly tales intertwined with St. Augustine’s long history.