Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whiskey Tasting

Whether you’re a seasoned whisky lover or just curious about the world’s favorite amber nectar, the Edinburgh Lost Close Whisky Tasting offers a distinctive experience. Set in a newly uncovered underground vault beneath Edinburgh’s Old Town, this tour blends history, storytelling, and tasting in a way that truly elevates your appreciation for Scotch.

What makes this tour special? First, it’s the exclusive underground venue—a hidden part of Edinburgh that feels like stepping into a secret world. Second, the guides are notably knowledgeable and engaging, bringing stories of Scotland’s whisky characters and industry to life. Third, the opportunity to upgrade your tasting experience—whether to rarer, older drams or high-end selections—adds a personalized touch.

The only thing to consider? The tour’s focus on whisky means it’s not suitable for children, pregnant women, or those with mobility challenges, given the underground setting. But if you’re after an authentic, educational, and atmospheric whisky adventure, this is a winner. Perfect for history buffs, spirits enthusiasts, or anyone looking to deepen their understanding of Scotland’s national drink, all while enjoying a fun, social atmosphere.

Key Points

• Unique setting: An underground vault uncovered in Edinburgh’s Old Town makes for a memorable atmosphere.
• Expert guides: Knowledgeable and personable guides share fascinating stories and details behind each whisky.
• Regional variety: Taste whiskies from all major Scottish regions, highlighting their differences.
• Upgrade options: Rarer, older, or high-end spirits are available for those seeking a more exclusive experience.
• Historical storytelling: The tour offers more than just tasting — it’s packed with Scottish whisky lore.
• Good value: The price includes four whiskies, a guided experience, and access to a truly unique venue, making it a worthwhile investment.

You can check availability for your dates here:

Exploring Edinburgh’s Hidden Spirit: The Complete Experience

Setting the Scene: An Underground Journey Begins

Starting at John’s Coffee House & Tavern, your adventure kicks off in a cozy, historic setting. From there, you follow your guide behind the Mercat Cross on the Royal Mile, passing a statue of James Braidwood before entering the hidden entrance to The Lost Close. It’s here that your journey into Edinburgh’s underground begins—an atmospheric, newly uncovered space that feels like a secret lair for whisky enthusiasts.

This initial part of the experience is practical and straightforward — your guide will set expectations and introduce the history of the underground vaults. It’s a great way to build anticipation before descending into the cool, stone-lined cellar where the tasting takes place.

The Guided Tour: Stories and Scottish Spirit Lore

The 20-minute guided walk through The Lost Close is a highlight in itself. Your guide, often praised for their enthusiasm and knowledge, shares stories about Edinburgh’s history, especially how whisky played a part in shaping Scottish identity. Reviewers mention guides like Nickey and Sarah, who excel at combining humor with historical facts, making the experience both entertaining and educational.

Expect to learn about the characters and events that pushed Scotch whisky to global fame. From quirky distillery anecdotes to tales of whisky pirates and characters who helped shape the industry, the storytelling adds depth beyond what you’d find in a typical bar.

The Tasting: A Flavorful Exploration

The core of the experience is the scotch tasting session lasting about 70 minutes. You’ll sample four different whiskies, each representing one of Scotland’s major regions — Lowland, Highland, Speyside, and Islay. This regional approach makes it easier to appreciate the diverse flavors, aromas, and styles that Scottish whisky offers.

Guests have shared that the whisky selection is thoughtfully curated: “You’re introduced to whiskies from each region and learn how they differ.” Reviewers also appreciate the atmosphere of the underground space, which boosts the sensory experience, making each sip feel more special.

More Great Tours Nearby

Upgrading the Experience: Rarer and Top-Shelf Spirits

For those wanting more, the upgrade options are a real treat. The intermediate tasting includes four drams of rarer, older, and more unusual whiskies — things you’re unlikely to find in local shops. Many reviewers found this to be a highlight, saying, “The rarer spirits added a layer of exclusivity and excitement.”

The high-end option offers five premium drams, giving a tasting of some of the most sought-after whiskies on the market. While this elevates the experience, it still remains good value, considering the quality and exclusivity of what you’re tasting.

The Atmosphere and Group Dynamics

Guests consistently praise the friendly, knowledgeable guides who keep the atmosphere lively and welcoming. The small group sizes (generally around 10-15 people) foster intimacy and make it easy to ask questions or seek personalized recommendations.

Many reviews mention the guides’ ability to interweave humor and Scottish lore seamlessly, making the whole experience feel relaxed yet informative. “The guide’s enthusiasm and humor made it feel more like a chat with a friend who’s a whisky expert,” said one visitor.

Practical Details: Duration, Cost, and Accessibility

At 1.5 hours, the tour fits well into a busy sightseeing schedule. The cost, which covers four whiskies and expert guidance, is quite reasonable—especially considering the quality of the spirits and the unique underground venue. The option to upgrade adds a layer of personalization without significantly raising the price.

However, it’s important to note that the underground location is not wheelchair accessible, and the tour isn’t suitable for children, pregnant women, or those with mobility restrictions. The venue’s historic nature means stairs might be involved in the underground walk.

Transportation isn’t included, so plan your arrival at the meeting point in advance. The starting point, John’s Coffee House & Tavern, is conveniently located on the Royal Mile, making it easy to find and nearby other attractions.

Why This Tour Stands Out

What makes the Lost Close Whisky Tasting worth considering? Its authenticity. It’s not just a tasting in a bar; it’s an experience in a hidden Edinburgh venue that adds a layer of mystery and intimacy. The guides’ expertise and storytelling ability elevate the experience from mere tasting to culture.

The regional diversity of whiskies means you’ll leave with a better understanding of what sets Scotch apart across its different styles. The upgrade options are perfect for enthusiasts who want to explore rarer or more premium spirits, making it a flexible experience for different levels of whisky interest.

Most guests leave feeling more confident in their whisky knowledge, often remarking that the experience “began their journey to becoming a whisky connoisseur,” as one reviewer described.

Final Thoughts: Is It Worth It?

This tour is a superb choice if you’re after an authentic, immersive whisky experience amid Edinburgh’s historic underground. Its small group size and friendly guides make it ideal for those who want a personal touch, while the storytelling ensures you’ll learn something new about Scottish history and whisky craftsmanship.

While it’s not designed for those with mobility issues or families with young children, for adult visitors seeking a well-rounded, fun, and educational tasting, this experience offers great value at a reasonable price.

If you’re traveling through Edinburgh and want to combine history, culture, and spirits in one memorable package, this underground whisky tasting could very well be a highlight of your trip.

FAQ

Is transportation included in this tour?
No, transportation isn’t provided. You’ll need to make your way to the meeting point at John’s Coffee House & Tavern, which is centrally located on the Royal Mile.

How long does the entire tour last?
The experience lasts about 1.5 hours, including the guided walk and tasting.

Can I upgrade my whisky tasting?
Yes, there are options to upgrade to either a medium or high-end tasting, featuring rarer and premium spirits.

What can I expect at the underground venue?
The venue is a recently uncovered underground space beneath Edinburgh’s Old Town, offering a historic, atmospheric setting that enhances the tasting experience.

Are children allowed on this tour?
No, the tour is for ages 18 and above, as it involves whisky tasting and there are restrictions on pregnant women and those with mobility issues.

Is the experience suitable for people with dietary restrictions?
The tour focuses on whisky and storytelling; food isn’t included, so dietary restrictions related to food are not relevant here.

What’s included in the price?
The cost covers four whisky samples from major Scottish regions, guidance from knowledgeable hosts, and access to the underground venue. Upgrades are optional.

Is the tour wheelchair accessible?
Unfortunately, no. The underground location involves stairs and uneven surfaces, making it unsuitable for wheelchair users.

How do I find the meeting point?
Meet your guide in the reception area of John’s Coffee House & Tavern, behind the Mercat Cross on the Royal Mile. Look for the statue of James Braidwood.

Would I recommend this experience?
Absolutely, especially for those interested in Scottish whisky, history, and unique underground settings. It’s a balanced mix of education, entertainment, and cultural discovery.

In essence, the Edinburgh Lost Close Whisky Tasting offers a rare glimpse into Scotland’s spirit industry, layered with stories and set in a compelling historic environment. It’s a perfect pick for curious travelers eager to taste and learn in equal measure, making it a memorable part of any Edinburgh trip.

You can check availability for your dates here: